The Construction of Factuality in Pakistan’s Legal Discourse: A Stylistic Analysis of Logical Fallacies
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26710/reads.v5i2.630Keywords:
Legal Discourse, Legal Text, Legalese, Stylistics, Logical Fallacies, Supreme Court, FactualityAbstract
Factuality remains the highest virtue of a legal text. The paper finds how this virtue is jeopardized by the presence of logical fallacies. The stylistics analysis is performed for identification of linguistic features of logical fallacies in legal language. Two randomly selected verdicts of the Supreme Court of Pakistan are selected for analysis. Analysis of verdicts reveals that factuality is compromised by fallacies with distinctive stylistic features. These features include the fallacies of relevance, defective induction and ambiguity. Lexical choices, syntactically complicated structure and graphological markers of style contribute to the formation of these fallacies. The findings establish that stylistic aspect themselves contribute to the projection of fallacies in verdicts, therefore, the study recommends avoiding stylistic formulae of the legalese or legal registers which lead to the formation of logical fallacies in the legal language.
References
Ahmad, A., & Khan, A. (2016). Integration Through Language in the Pak-Afghan Borderland: The Interplay of past legacies, present realities and future scenarios. Central Asia Journal, 79(winter), 33-51.
Ahmad, M., Nadeem, M. T., Khan, T., & Ahmad, S. (2015). Stylistic Analysis of the 'Mulsim Family Laws Ordinance 1961'. Journal for the Study of English Linguistics, 3(1), 28-37.
Al-Hindawi, F. H., Alkhazaali, M. A., & Al-Awadi, D. (2015).A Pragmatic Study of Fallacy in David Cameron's Poltical Speeches. Journal of Social Science Studies, 2(2), 214-239.
Alabi, V. A. (2003). Stylistic Features of the Legal Discourse.In A. Lawal (Ed.), Stylistic theory and practice (pp. 106-118). Ilorin: Paragon Books.
Asghar, S. A., Mahmood, M. A., &Asghar, Z. (2018). Linguistic Variation Across Pakistani Genres: A Multimodal Analysis. ELF Annual Research Journal, 20, 133-158.
Asghar, S. A., Mahmood, M. A., &Asghar, Z. M. (2018).A Multidimensional Analysis of Pakistani Legal English. International Journal of English Linguistics, 8(5), 215-229.
Azmat, Z. (2017). Nees Analysis and Syllabus Design of Legal Language for the Students of Law at AMU: An ESP Approach. International Journal of English Language, Literature in Humanities, 5(10), 466-475.
Bennet, B. (2012). Logical Fallacies: The Ultimate Collection of Over 300 Logical Fallacies. Sudbury, MA: eBookIt.com.
Bloomfield, M. W. (1976). Stylistics and the Theory of Literature. New Literary Theory, 7(2), 271-311.
Changing Works.(2019). Aristotle's 13 fallacies. Retrieved March 23, 2019, from http://changingminds.org/disciplines/argument/fallacies/aristotle_fallacies.htm
Copi, I. M., & Cohen, C. (2014). Introduction to Logic (14 ed.). Essex, England: Pearson.
Danet, B. (1985). Legal Discourse.In T. A. Van Dijk (Ed.), Handbook of Discourse Analysis. London: Academic Press.
Fischer, D. H. (1970). Historians' fallacies: Toward a logic of historical thought. New York, NY: Harper & Row.
Fish, S. (1970). Literature in the Reader: Affective Stylistics. New Literary History, 2(1), 123-162.
Gozdz-Rszkowski, S. (2011). Discovering Patterns and Meaning: Corpus Perspectives on Phraseology in Legal Discourse. Frankfurt: Peter Lang
Halper, T. (1968).Logic in Judicial Reasoning. Indiana Law Journal, 44(1), 33-48.
Hansen, H. V. (1996). Aristotle, Whately, and the taxonomy of fallacies, Berlin, Heidelberg.
Hernandez, H. P. (2017). A (Forensic) Stylistic Analysis of Adverbials of Attitude and Emphasis in Supreme Court Decisions in Philippine English. Indonesian Journal of Applied Linguistics, 7(2), 455-466.
Kruchinina, O. (2019). Stylistics as a branch of linguistics.The Problems of stylistic research. Retrieved March 23, 2019, from https://www.academia.edu/10756244/1._Stylistics_as_a_branch_of_linguistics._The_problem_of_stylistic_research
McClurg, A. J. (1988). Logical Fallacies and the Supreme Court: A Critical Analysis of Justice Rehnquist's Decisions in Criminal Procedure Cases. University of Colorado Law Review, 59, 741-845.
Merriam-Webster.(2019). Stylistics. Retrieved March 22, 2019, from https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/stylistics
Nawaz, N., Bilal, H. A., Khan, T., & Ahmed, I. (2013). Language of Law: Stylistic Analysis of a Legal Document. International Journal of Research in Management, 2(3), 221-243.
Nordquist, R. (2018). Stylistics and Element of Style in Literature. Retrieved March 22, 2019, from https://www.thoughtco.com/stylistics-language-studies-1692000
Sharma, R. S. (2004). Applied Linguistics : Stylistics And Language Teaching. New Delhi, India: Atlantic Publishers & Distributors (P) Limited.
Tiersma, P. (1999). Legal Language. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Wales, K. (2001). A Dictionary of Stylistics. Harlow: Longman.
Wetherill, P. M. (1974). The Literary Text: An Examination of Critical Methods. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Widdowson, H. G. (1975). Stylistics and the Teaching of Literature. Harlow Longman.
